Menu

Who Took The Falling Soldier? An Interview with José Manuel Serrano Esparza

26 • 11 • 22 László Baki Time to read: 9 min

The authorship of Robert Capa’s iconic photograph has been debated for decades. According to photographic history researcher José Manuel Serrano Esparza, the photograph was taken by Robert Capa, and identifying Gerda Taro’s camera does not in itself prove otherwise. He supports his argument through technical analysis, contemporary photographs and documentation establishing the chronology of his discovery.

L.B.

How did you identify Gerda Taro’s camera in the photographs taken near Villa del Río in 1936, and why do you consider this discovery important?

J.M.S.E.

In December 2013, I read Irme Schaber’s biography of Gerda Taro. It was through this book that I learned that, in 1935, Taro had used her first salary to buy a Reflex Korelle, a single-lens reflex camera that used 6 × 6 cm negatives, which she later used during the Spanish Civil War. Previously, many people had believed that she had photographed with a twin-lens Rolleiflex.

I wanted to find a photograph of Taro holding this camera. For months, I studied her photographs, examined books and watched documentaries, and even acquired a Reflex Korelle myself so that I could familiarise myself with its construction, controls and shape.

In September 2014, while watching the documentary Robert Capa in Love and War, I came across the photograph I had been looking for. In the image, Taro is holding a camera whose large, angular central section, thinner rounded sides and protruding lens clearly resemble the distinctive features of the Reflex Korelle. The image quality was not particularly good, but I was able to identify the camera from these details.

I published my discovery in English on my blog on 24 September 2014, followed by a Spanish version the next day. On 29 September, I submitted the documentation of my research to the Intellectual Property Registry in Madrid, where it was registered under number M-006885/2014. The procedure was completed on 30 October. Two months later, the Spanish magazine FV Foto-Vídeo Actualidad also published my research. In 2021, higher-quality images published on the website of the International Center of Photography (ICP) in New York provided further evidence supporting the identification.

0103

Picture from TV screen of the documentary film " Robert Capa in Love and War " (produced and directed in 2002 by Anne Makepeace for the TV Series American Masters and broadcast to millions of people in United States by the PBS TV channel) made by José Manuel Serrano Esparza in early September of 2014. But the shape and contours of this big camera were very different to the rest of medium format cameras at the time (Rolleiflex Old Standard 6 x 6 cm, Zeiss Ikon Super Ikontas 6 x 9 cm, Voigtlander 6 x 9, etc),

0103

Reflex Korelle main dials and controls. The camera is with its waist level viewfinder hood up. © José Manuel Serrano Esparza

L.B.

Could the fact that Taro is holding a Reflex Korelle be evidence that she took The Falling Soldier?

J.M.S.E.

In my opinion, no. The fact that Taro is seen holding a Reflex Korelle in the photographs taken near Villa del Río proves that she used this camera. It does not, however, prove that she took The Falling Soldier.

My position is that the photograph was taken by Robert Capa using a Leica II Model D camera, which used 24 × 36 mm negatives and was fitted with a Leitz Elmar 50 mm f/3.5 lens. The image’s technical characteristics – including its framing and grain – together with Capa’s photographic style, support this conclusion.

A 6 × 6 cm negative has a considerably larger area than a 24 × 36 mm Leica frame. We would generally expect it to capture more detail, produce finer tonal gradations and show less noticeable grain. Yet the known versions of The Falling Soldier display significant grain. The composition is also an important clue: the bottom edge of the image cuts off part of the militiaman’s leg, while his face is blurred by movement. I consider these imperfections consistent with Capa’s quick, instinctive way of photographing.

Capa often moved close to his subjects and did not always frame his shots precisely when trying to capture a moment. The rangefinder viewfinder of a Leica can produce parallax between what the photographer sees and what the lens records, particularly at close distances. The same phenomenon does not occur in the same way with a single-lens reflex camera. For this reason, I also consider the cropped leg an important technical detail.

Taken together, these factors lead me to conclude that the photograph was most likely made with a Leica II Model D on 24 × 36 mm film. I must emphasise, however, that the original negative has been lost, so the format cannot be verified directly.

0103

Photo : Robert Capa / © ICP New York

L.B.

What role does the difference between Capa’s and Taro’s photographic vision play in your argument?

J.M.S.E.

Capa and Taro were both significant photographers, but they worked in different ways. Capa’s images are often characterised by proximity, movement and the intensity of the moment. He reacted quickly to events, moved close to people and was able to use motion blur to enhance the expressive power of an image.

In Taro’s early photographs, by contrast, composition and the use of diagonals and geometric forms are often more prominent. Her images also reflect the influence of Constructivism and the visual language of the avant-garde. This does not mean that she was less capable of capturing the dynamism of wartime situations or conveying human emotions; rather, she approached them using different visual means.

Taro began photographing in Spain in August 1936, whereas Capa already had several years of professional photojournalistic experience by that time. Taro’s 6 × 6 cm Reflex Korelle was also heavier and slower to operate than Capa’s Leica. A roll of film provided twelve exposures, compared with the Leica’s 36, and operating the camera required more steps. The movement of the mirror during exposure could also make it more difficult to avoid camera shake.

Nevertheless, Taro produced excellent photographs. Her work entered a new phase when she began using the Leica III in February 1937. Her later reportage – including photographs taken in Valsequillo, around La Granjuela and during the Battle of Brunete – demonstrates her maturity as a photojournalist. I believe it is important that the debate over authorship should not overshadow the significance of Taro’s independent body of work.

0103

Three Republican militiawomen, probably in Barcelona. August 1936. Photo : Gerda Taro / © ICP New York.

0103

Republican militiamen inside a Popular Front car speaking with two militiawomen beside it. Barcelona. August 1936. Photo : Gerda Taro / © ICP New York.

L.B.

What do we know about the circumstances in which the photograph was taken, and how can we distinguish a staged scene from a staged photograph?

J.M.S.E.

The photograph was taken during the first week of September 1936, near Espejo in Spain, in extremely strong sunlight. In the surrounding images, militiamen can be seen running, jumping, posing and pretending to fire their weapons. On the basis of these photographs, I consider it clear that some of the scenes were directed by someone. However, I do not believe that this was done by either Capa or Taro.

An older man wearing a military cap appears in several photographs, giving instructions to the militiamen. By comparing the images, I concluded that he was directing their movements and poses while Capa and Taro photographed them. The man was later identified as Rafael Medina Ramírez, known as “El Berenjeno”; the identification was reported by the Spanish newspaper Público in 2011.

The distinction is crucial: the fact that people in a photograph are posing at someone’s instruction does not necessarily mean that the photographer invented or staged the scene. In my interpretation, Capa and Taro documented situations that arose as a result of instructions given by the militiamen’s commander.

Capa did not speak Spanish, while Taro had some knowledge of the language. However, in the photographs I have examined, she cannot be identified as the person directing the scenes. In my view, the man’s position of authority and the way the militiamen respond to him support the conclusion that he ordered their movements. This is, of course, a conclusion drawn from the photographs I have studied, rather than a fact that can be directly verified from the lost negative.

0103

Selective frame of the image, including the lower half of Gerda Taro´s photograph showing five militiamen (one of them being The Falling Soldier) and the mature officer with military cap on the right of the image, very clearly giving orders to the militiamen regarding the movements they have to do while being photographed. It is very evident that this mature officer was the person who gave the orders to the militiamen that day and how they had to run, direction of the runnings and jumpings, how to pose, etc.

L.B.

The original negative has been lost. What evidence can still help establish the photograph’s format and authorship? What does this case teach us about photographic history research?

J.M.S.E.

In the case of The Falling Soldier, neither the original negative nor, to my knowledge, an original print has survived. The aspect ratios of the versions published in different sources vary: some are closer to the 24 × 36 mm format, while others resemble a 4:5 aspect ratio associated with larger-format photography. The version published in Vu magazine in 1936 is more panoramic, whereas the 1937 version in Life is darker, and the upper part of the image may also have been altered.

John G. Morris, the former picture editor of Life, told me personally that photographs at the magazine were frequently retouched, darkened and recropped to make them fit the page layout better. He also considered such alterations likely in the case of the version published in Life. This is important because the aspect ratio of a print known today cannot automatically be used to determine the dimensions of the original negative.

The claim attributed to the ICP that the image was made from a 6 × 6 cm negative is also disputed. Alfonso del Barrio, editor of FV Foto-Vídeo Actualidad, contacted the institution, and according to the response he received, the ICP did not confirm this claim. I consider this significant because an institution’s position should not be quoted without verification.

For me, the lesson of this research is that claims about photographic history must be supported by multiple forms of evidence: technical analysis of images, comparison of contemporary publications, knowledge of how cameras work, and documentation of research findings. It is equally important to establish an accurate chronology of discoveries and acknowledge the work of earlier researchers.

In the digital media landscape, novelty and speed often take precedence over careful verification. Yet in the case of a disputed photograph, it is particularly important for journalists, researchers and institutions to examine their sources and correct any errors that may have been published.

I have been working on this subject for thirty-two years. I am convinced that The Falling Soldier was taken by Robert Capa.

Notes

Further information regarding José Manuel Serrano Esparza's research on Capa is available on his blog.